By Tyler Arnold
Washington, D.C. Newsroom, Aug 8, 2025 /
15:23 pm
A 28-year-old man was found guilty of assaulting two elderly pro-life activists in front of the Planned Parenthood facility in Baltimore but was sentenced to just one year of home detention and avoided any jail time.
Judge Yvette M. Bryant handed down Patrick Brice’s sentence after he was found guilty of assaulting then-84-year-old Richard Schaefer and then-73-year-old Mark Crosby on May 26, 2023, when the two were providing sidewalk counseling in which they encouraged potential Planned Parenthood clients to choose life instead of getting an abortion.
The Baltimore Banner reported that Brice told the judge: “I just snapped one day” during the sentencing hearing and apologized to the victims. The outlet reported that Crosby shouted “What about my rights and well-being?” at Bryant after she delivered the lenient sentence.
Prosecutors had hoped to put Brice behind bars for 10 years, and the Thomas More Society condemned the sentence as “disgraceful.”
“One of the victims was knocked unconscious. The other suffered broken facial bones and a lifelong eye impairment,” said Tom Brejcha, the president and chief counsel for the Thomas More Society, which provided Crosby with victim’s counsel after the attack.
“This was an act of cowardice and cruelty, and sheer mayhem,” Brejcha continued. “This crime deserves far more serious consequences than a ‘get out of jail free’ card and a one-year home detention that amounts to nothing more than a slap on the wrist.”
CNA interviewed both Schaefer and Crosby after the attack in 2023. They both kept up their pro-life activism outside of the Baltimore Planned Parenthood in spite of their injuries.
At the time, Schaefer said he had a brief discussion with Brice that was “kind of cordial” before the attack. When he turned around and bent down to replenish some of the pro-life material he was handing out, Brice knocked him into a plate-glass window and then kicked him after he had fallen to the ground.
When Crosby rushed over to help, Brice hit him in the face and then kicked him after he hit the ground.
Crosby suffered a severe concussion, fractured fingers, and a lifelong eye impairment. At the time, he had internal bleeding in one of his eyes and temporarily lost sight in that eye. Schafer did not go to the hospital immediately but saw a doctor later, after he realized he was bleeding from his head. He said Crosby’s intervention likely saved him from more serious injuries.
Brejcha said the light sentence “sends a dangerous message that pro-lifers can be attacked with impunity” and warned that it “not only jeopardizes the safety of peaceful demonstrators, but it undermines the rule of law and the right to free speech.”
“No one should fear being beaten on the sidewalk for simply standing up for the most vulnerable among us,” Brejcha said. “Violence must never be tolerated, excused, or minimized, especially when it’s politically motivated. Justice was not served in this case, and we must continue to fight until all peaceful pro-life voices are protected.”
Tyler Arnold is a staff reporter for Catholic News Agency, based in EWTN News’ Washington Bureau. He previously worked at The Center Square and has been published in a variety of outlets, including The Associated Press, National Review, The American Conservative, and The Federalist.
